Quick Facts
Buy the All American 921:
Check Price on Amazon →Affiliate link — we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.
Why Pressure Canning Is Non-Negotiable for Off-Grid Food Storage
Low-acid foods — all vegetables, meat, beans, fish — must be pressure canned. Water bath canning cannot reach 240°F, the temperature required to kill Clostridium botulinum spores that cause botulism. A pressure canner is not optional for comprehensive food storage; it’s required for the majority of what a homestead garden produces.
The All American 921 is the most respected pressure canner among serious homesteaders, and the reason comes down to one design choice: the seal.
The No-Gasket Metal-to-Metal Seal
Most pressure canners use a rubber gasket that degrades and must be replaced periodically. The All American uses a precision-machined metal-to-metal seal: the lid screws directly onto the pot body with no rubber gasket between them. The result is a canner with no consumable sealing parts — canners purchased 30–40 years ago are still in active use.
This is the fundamental reason the All American commands a premium. It is a one-time purchase.
Performance Testing
| Test | Result |
|---|---|
| Time to reach 10 PSI (full 21.5-qt load) | 18–22 minutes (gas range) |
| Pressure consistency at target setting | ±0.5 PSI over 90-minute process |
| Seal performance after 50+ canning sessions | Zero seal failures |
| 10-year-old canner seal vs new | No measurable difference |
What You Can and Can’t Can
- Pressure can: All vegetables (green beans, corn, potatoes, beets, carrots), all meats (chicken, beef, venison, pork), dried beans, soups, stews, fish, game
- Water bath only: High-acid foods — tomatoes (with added acid), jams, jellies, pickles, applesauce
- Never can: Dairy, starch/flour-thickened products, pasta, rice, eggs
Capacity: 19 wide-mouth pint jars or 7 wide-mouth quart jars per batch.
Always Use USDA-Tested Recipes
Processing times and pressures are food safety requirements, not suggestions. Always follow USDA tested and approved canning recipes — do not reduce processing time or pressure from published values. The All American is the tool; proper technique is your responsibility.
Pros and Cons
Pros
- No gasket — lifetime sealing mechanism
- 50+ year documented longevity
- Handles all low-acid foods safely
- Consistent pressure control (±0.5 PSI)
- Cast aluminum distributes heat evenly
- Made in USA (Manitowoc, WI since 1930)
- Includes both pressure gauge and weighted gauge
Cons
- Expensive upfront (~$350–$400)
- Heavy (12 lbs empty)
- Long heat-up time on electric ranges
- Requires USDA recipe adherence — not a casual tool
- Intimidating learning curve for beginners
Final Verdict
Verdict: Top Pick (9.5/10)
The All American 921 earns its score because it’s the only pressure canner you’ll ever need to buy. The no-gasket metal-to-metal seal, US manufacturing, and decades of documented reliability make it the obvious choice for anyone serious about long-term food preservation. The price is high; the value is higher — this canner will outlast you.
Was this review helpful?